Back-to-School Heart Sugar Cookies
🍎 Sweet ABCs & a Pencil-Wrapped Surprise
Back-to-school heart sugar cookies the school season is upon us—and what better way to celebrate than with cookies that say “Welcome Back!” in the sweetest way possible? These heart-shaped sugar cookies are more than just tasty—they’re full of charm, personality, and school spirit!
I’ve created two heart designs to kick off this back-to-school cookie series. Whether you’re just starting out or ready for a challenge, you’ll find one that fits your style. So roll out that dough, fill those piping bags, and let’s decorate with a little love (and a lot of royal icing!).
❤️ Design #1: ABC Heart Cookie (Beginner-Friendly)
This cookie is perfect for new decorators, kids, or busy bakers looking to add a thoughtful touch without too much fuss.
What You’ll Need:
- Heart-shaped sugar cookie
- Red royal icing (medium & piping consistency)
- Black royal icing (piping consistency, #1 tip) or an edible marker
Unlock Your 51 Page “Free” Sugar Cookie & Royal Icing Toolkit Today!
The Beautiful, printable Sugar Cookie & Royal Icing recipe cards are included inside your FREE Toolkit — Grab it for the prettiest version to save, print, or add to you binder 🍬✨
Say Goodbye to baking stress and Hello to Cookie Perfection. You’ll receive your comprehensive toolkit filled with recipes and guides to transform your Cooking-Making Experience
Your Toolkit is just a click away!
How to Decorate:
- Outline and flood the heart using red royal icing. Tip: Before filling and to minimize concaved icing, scribble some icing near the center of the heart and then begin flood filling from the outside to center.
- Allow it to set fully—An hour or so will work but, overnight is best!
- Using a black #1 tip (or edible marker), pipe three charmingly imperfect letters: A, B, and C. Feel free to get playful—the more “first-grade handwriting,” the better!
📸 Pro Tip: These are perfect for lunchbox treats or teacher appreciation gifts.
🎥 Watch the full ABC Heart video tutorial here!
✏️ Design #2: Pencil-Wrapped Heart Cookie (Mid-to-Advanced)
This one’s a showstopper! Inspired by a special request from my grandchild, this cookie wraps a classic #2 pencil around the curves of a heart—complete with 3D details and a little surprise in the center!
What You’ll Need:
- Heart-shaped cookie
- White royal icing (outline: #1 tip, flood: #3 tip)
- Yellow, pink, brown, and black royal icing (all medium-flood consistency)
- Toothpick or scribe tool
✏️ Back-to-School & Sweet as Ever
Explore the full roundup of school-themed cookie fun!
How to Decorate:
- Start by outlining the heart in white with a #1 tip.
- Using a #3 tip, scribble icing into the center of the heart first (this helps prevent concaving!) and flood around the outline. Let it set.
- Once dry, outline and flood a yellow pencil shape that wraps around about ¾ of the heart, ending above the tip. You want space to add the writing tip and pencil eraser.
- Keep the yellow icing slightly thicker than typical flood to give that puffy, dimensional pencil look.
- After that sets, add the details:
- black metal band
- Pink eraser
- Brown exposed wood
- Black pencil tip
- Using a black #1 tip, pipe fine pencil lines to add depth and realism.
- In the center of the heart, create a pink heart using two dots of icing joined at the bottom point with icing or a scribe tool.
💡 Note: The heart’s puffiness and precision come from drying in stages—don’t rush this one!
🎥 Watch the Pencil-Wrapped Heart tutorial here!
🧁 Decorating Tips & Tricks:
- Slightly thicker yellow icing = puffier pencil = more dimension!
- Scribble icing in the center of your flood first to help prevent sunken cookies.
- Use a scribe or toothpick to nudge icing into corners or fix tiny gaps.
- Add a name instead of the pink heart, “Welcome Back,” or even a teacher’s initials for a personal touch!
✨ Want to Dress Up Your Cookie Gifts?
Grab this free printable set of cookie tags and care cards in 3 gorgeous colors — perfect for gifting with a personal touch. Just sign up below and they’re yours!
These heart cookies are a sweet way to say “I care” at the start of the school year. Whether you’re making them for your little ones, gifting them to teachers, or just enjoying a little creative fun, don’t forget: imperfect is beautiful—especially when it’s covered in royal icing. 💖
Pin & Share!!!
